Changing tastes...

I've been here since we were at our old domain, and upon reflection, I've changed a lot. I started with a lot of aros--mostly blends from a B&M in Waco that my friend swore by; Captain Black; SWR; etc. I was attracted to Danish pipes and shapes. My first briar was a Nording bent apple, and my second was a Tsuge Arashi, a dublin/mild-horn with a plateau top. Now...

Petersons. Dunhills. Flakes. Latakia. I find my tastes are varied, but focused to a few. I bought my first estate pipe about a week or so ago, and after topping it, it's probably my best smoker (a 1928 Dunhill 107). I've fallen in love with Pete's...I own 4 now, and will be 5 when my churchwarden comes in. I scoffed at those who liked the classic shapes. "Boring!" "Too old!" "Classic? Says who!" Those were my remarks, opinions, thoughts. Now? Couldn't be further from reality.

Well, ain't it funny, I suppose...

Comments

muddler's picture

I went through an almost

I went through an almost identical process - both with pipes & tobacco. Started on aro's, went through the entire gamut of varieties & am now fixed on Va flakes as a core with more English coming into the mix during winter. Pipe-wise, after accumulating every manner of shape & size, I settled on Italian makers for a while. I too thought Dunhills were plain. Then I started collecting GBD's, with a few Dunnies as well. Now it's classic shapes for me. And I still love my Pete's through it all. Yes, it is funny.

mclayton's picture

Ain't that ironic, Muddler!

I too have started looking at Savs, Costellos, and such. I just think it's a maturation process, ya know?

My pipe mentor, who's been smoking for 10 years and has about 300 pipes, is still stuck on aros. However, I guess Ive become more of the mentor figure. He bought Davidoff Scottish Mixture, and now cleans his pipes! His father, a piper for 40 years, almost patently refuses to even run a cleaner through his pipes weekly. I had the chore of cleaning a Nording of his for a few dollars, and I should've charged for a full refurb...and he had it for a year!

I guess the final nail in this coffin was putting my BC Negoita up for sale. I still love seeing the artisans (I'm in the common sewers group at SF), but I just don't get pulled to them anymore.

muddler's picture

I'm also a sewer rat but

I'm also a sewer rat but don't post there very often. I do like to see some of the very beautiful custom pipes but will probably never end up collecting them (although I have a few customs). Classic lines & old wood is what I appreciate most. I also love Pete's, not just the old English pipes - they have a unique classicism about them that I find very appealing.

mclayton's picture

Absolutely

I'm a big history buff. Holding the 1928 Dunhill, it wasn't necessarily like "oh I'm holding an old pipe," but rather, I'm holding and puffing on a piece linked in history. It has seen the Great Depression, WW2, the moon landing, assassinations, etc.

Peterson's also have that draw to me. From the system to the other types, there's something about being honed over time that really draws to me...

vasco's picture

While Petes were my first

While Petes were my first love I decided that I have enough and that I prefer the wood in the Italian pipes.
That was before I got my Barling, now I know what a really old pipe feel like, and I can tell that there is a huge difference in holding a 1990 (possibly) Savinelli and a 1960's Barling, I could tell which is which just by touching the wood (without feeling the shape).
I wonder what was the "life" of that pipe from the factory somewhere on England to a flea market near my house.
But I think that my major taste change was from bent pipes to straight. While at first I loved the OmPauls and other full bents, right now I prefer the Canadians, Lovats and other types of long sranked pipes.
While I don't care much for the big names like Dunhill or Castello I want to get some artisan pipes, specially from the ones that we can talk with, Sparks, ckr, Askwith, Quagliata and others.

Tim's picture

Pipes and time

Funny how my pipe smoking has changed over time: I used to some a bowl now and again, but over time it's become a steady habit and perhaps the best way for me to enjoy a repast during the day (and a fine accompaniment to a dog walk). I appreciate age in both my bowls and my tobacco more and more, which is a sign of maturation in both the habit and the smoker, I imagine. Inevitably, I think, a lot of us develop a better appreciation of the nuances of construction in both blending and pipe craft, enriching our enjoyment. Never much of an aro smoker, I still find a great deal to explore among English and VaPer and Flakes.

Steve G's picture

I found I have completed a circle.

I found the old site in September of 2008 when I first moved to DC. Having a bunch of time on my hands, as I had not found a new job. At that time, I spent most of my afternoons smoking two different aromatics. One called Saint Nicks, an aromatic cherry blend, the other blend was similar to 1Q.

During October of those years 1OldGI always mentioned Codger Burley's (PA, Carter Hall, Half and Half, Edgeworth) and Heritage Blends (Old Joe Krantz, Pegasus, Haunted Bookshop). I followed the burley kick for many a month, and in spring of 2009 I found english blends, by way of Penzanze. I later discovered all of the Frog Morton series.

A month ago I VA blends, and VA/Per blends. But I am now on an aromatic kick again.

Captain Bob's picture

There was a time when...

... I would only buy Savinelli's, then a time Butz-Choquin. And, now it is just Bob Hayes. Follow your heart. Smoke the pipes you love and love the pipes you smoke.

BobB's picture

My Wife Would Disagree

But this is one place I can't be wrong. Borkum and Captain Black to start out 30+ years ago along with several from Tinder Box. About three years ago when I got serious, I started sampling. I still smoke mostly aro's, but am pretty solid with my 'Island Selection' of eleven that I've had for a year.
Pipewise, I always enjoyed freehands in a bent dubby shape. I lean tward capped bent dubby's now as they hang well and are easier to scoop into the pouch with. I've got lots of Pete's and find them predictable and worth the money. My wiley's are lovely, smoke well, but a tad heavy. I don't know, maybe I'll look into estate's soon, pretty happy with my choices though...

Captain Bob's picture

BobB,

Your choiceas are just fine. I probably know you better than anyone else on this forum. Aro's are fine, too! According to Craig Tarler, 70% of the tobacco manufactured is aromatic. It's all a matter of degree. Remember, I "know" what you smoke and "what" you smoke are very mild Aro's from Milan. These are extraordinary tobacco's with true tobacco character. I would recommend them to any pipe smoker in a heartbeat! I especially like their "Our London Dock". It is an exceptional "mild" aromatic with excellent tobacco flavor.

"Bents" are "all" Craig smokes. He likes to "see" what he is lighting on fire!. I am headed that way, too. Even though I have several Canadians. I love my "bents" and will by more from Bob Hayes at the Chicago Show. By the way, I have one seat open if you want to fly down there with us on May 1st or 2nd. I have a room for you and will leave the light on fer ya! Can you make it?

BobB's picture

Alas, Captain

I'll still be doing overtime trying to pay off this third grandchild's opening to the new world. Then it's Christmas and both taxes again. My hope is to get in a hunt next year. I still have a dozen one pound jars to fill for this year, but hopefully that's it for PAD/TAD until 2011. I said 'hopefully' so don't all jump.

I don't just smoke 'mild aro's', but I reserve the serious tobac's for MY TIME which, again, I make very little of. 2015, 5110, Dark Star, Milan's 965 and Squadron Leader are for great books, great movies, great friends and to celebrate great times. I have five out of my forty or so pipes and of those straights, only the 'cool as hell' little Stanwell Vario poker get much use. Just not as comfortable the way I smoke'm. Hey, Bishop's Move could be voted on to the 'Island', very nice weed. Aro's for being around people just seem to work out better and around my wife, (not that she's not people, well.. she's really not to me, ah hell, let's not go there).

Thanks for the offer, but I can't. Really sucks because SoCal appears to be one of the SUCKIEST places for us. It's probably a good thing I treasure my own company.

I would like to get one more poker...

Captain Bob's picture

BobB,

No question about it... Bishop's Move is my favorite Latakia blend. I started smoking it way back in 1969 when I attended Marquette University. I smoked all of Uhle's blends during that period. They have all stood the test of time. But, Bishop's Move is exceptional to me. I usually find one or two times per week to smoke a huge bowl of Bishop's Move. Other than that, you know the routine... CBB and POG with a few loads of Gentleman Callers and Green River Vanilla many mornings whilst prancing on the treadmill watching the "Fixed" (Fox) News, CNBC and a little MSNBC. If the tradmill doesn't elevate my heart rate, the Political news usually does! God have mercy on us! Vote both major Parties to hell out. That's what I'll do. I have had it with both Parties. Let's get some "real" people in office that will work together and do the job they were elected to do and stop farting around...

Long Island pipe smoker's picture

Bob C you're just talkin Federal.....

Come to NY state where the gov is worthless and on the way out after the last gov Elliot Spitzer put himself out, the county executive just changed from Dem to Repub to seek the GOP nod for the guv race; and the local town is bankrupt and the MTA (all NYC bus subway and suburban commuter rail service like the Long Island Railroad) is bankrupt, school districts are out of funds and laying off teachers.....etc. My run on sentence is intentional. And just imagine for a moment, that I live in an affluent upscale university town with "renowned" schools. There are not enough votes in the rest of my lifetime to vote out all the wrongs that have taken place for the last 40 years that have brought us to the place we find outselves today. And when we vote out all the people in Washington, who is on deck to move in? I really feel between a rock and a hard place. That is why I retreat to my pipe and the hope of a home in the Vermont countryside where nobody can find me. Even the landline phone sucks. All I get are automated robo calls from political action groups and scams of every conceivable nature. I too am on blood pressure meds so I am going to shut up now.

Captain Bob's picture

LIP,

Still, we must try to keep a sense of humor about all this, despite how serious it is, or we may die sooner worrying about that which we may not be able to change. Don't worry, our children and grand children will be so desperate that they will have to clean the mess up. Then again, China will own us totally and will likely be making all of their decisions for them!

Long Island pipe smoker's picture

OK, now I'm not worrying

But I still do not have any Penzance. We are all sh!t out of luck one way or the other.